Phoenix Wright: Case Reviews – The First Turnabout

Little did anyone ever expect a text heavy, eccentric, Japanese video game series about courtroom dramas to become so popular worldwide, yet today Ace Attorney stands as one of Capcom’s most recognisable franchises. With six main releases, a handful of spin-offs and oddly guest appearances in a couple of fighting games, there’s a huge wealth of material to discover and relive in this franchise (there really are, check out some series stats here).

Every episode in the series has its high and low points, so to share some strong Ace Attorney love we’re reviewing each episode from the series. Spoilers of course will be minimised, but due to the nature of the games, they aren’t exactly avoidable. So let’s begin by going back to the start.

The First Turnabout

This is the first ever episode in the Ace Attorney series and the first time the series hero, Phoenix Wright, appears behind the defence’s bench as a qualified attorney. In terms of the timeline, there’s loads of material preceding this case, but these are matters for another day (although if anybody is interested in studying the Ace Attorney timeline, Kotaku have a great little piece here). The point is, this is the case that introduces to this world and its characters. As such, it’s the shortest and simplest episode the series has to offer.

Image result for the first turnabout
Mia Fey appears by Phoenix’s side in this episode. She’s a no nonsense mentor and acts as a pillar of strength for our hero in moments of doubt.

The case at hand involves Phoenix defending his friend, Larry Butz, who is accused of murdering his girlfriend simply because he was in the wrong place at the wrong time. However, there is no mystery to who the true culprit is, instead series creator and writer Shu Takumi ‘wanted players to focus on the thrill and excitement of nailing the culprit’. Other characters introduced to us are Phoenix’s mentor, Mia Fey, whose significance grows in cases to follow, Winston Payne, the feeble prosecuting opponent, and the judge, who becomes one of the most lovable characters of all despite his relatively plain appearance. Despite this, the real focus is certainly on catching the true killer in court and so everyone in this case really plays towards this common goal. This allows first case to be a thrilling run, which is pretty difficult to put down.

 

Image result for the first turnabout larry butz
I do know someone who was put off the games thanks to this creep. I like Larry Butz, but he is quite a lot to swallow…

Not that anyone would need to put it down, as the case is only a 30 minute affair. It’s over in a heartbeat, which is significant considering the length of the cases we see the series take on today. This can make ‘The First Turnabout’ feel a bit of a cop out to long-time fans, yet this provides the perfect package experience for first-time players. Whether we will invest in Phoenix Wright is down to how we receive this case and, as such its length really lends to the series’ favour. That is, if the eccentricities of Larry Butz haven’t turned players off already…

 

Image result for frank sahwit
Nice try Frank Sahwit, or should I say Frank Didit! Yeah, gotta love those name puns! (I’m pretty sure that joke was use in the episode itself…)

Ultimately though, this is a practical episode and if anyone were to replay it, we’d find very little room to stray from the main goal. The villain in this case, Frank Sahwit, has testimony longer than the judge’s beard, but pressing any statement really doesn’t provide much extra material for us to invest in. The flaws in his statements are extremely obvious and, if experienced a second time, questions how this case could ever have had another suspect to begin with. There is fun to be had by answering Mia’s questions at the start as wrong as possible, something not many players would likely delve into first time around.

 

Ultimately, ‘The First Turnabout’ does everything it needs to for first time players, but doesn’t really add anything but a short burst of nostalgia for long-time fans.

Case Rating – 6/10

Highlight Moment: Having Mia come up with lame excuses to leave after telling the judge she’s the defendant in the case. Stupid answers are not tolerated in court Phoenix!

Mia_Bench_Exasperated_2

If anyone would like to read more about ‘The First Turnabout’, then check out the link below!

http://www.capcom-unity.com/zeroobjections/blog/2014/09/12/the-early-days-of-ace-attorney

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s